To Review or Not to Review - That Is The Question

You're all excited. An author you've read before released another book. You plunk down your hard earned money and wait by your mailbos or open your Kindle.

The first half of the book pulls you in and you're on a wild ride. Oh, there are a few troublesome things, but you think to yourself the author didn't mean it THAT way.

And then, it gets weirder  and weirder.

The author crosses a line you've drawn in the sand - your, "I-can't-read-this-type-of-book" line. What do you do?

1.  Hope it will get better?

2.  Finish the book to see how the author justifies a foray into forbidden territory?

3.  Walk away and never look back?

4.  Write a scathing review?

5.  Try to find some redeeming lesson in the story?

This happened to me recently. I know how it feels to be so disappointed and upset after investing so much time reading a book.

I chose Option 3 - Walking away and never looking back. Options 1 and 2 didn't work for me since I'd already been trying to justify the storyline. Option 4 - I don't write this type of review - ever. Why?

1.  I don't want to bring attention to a book I feel might be detrimental to another person.

2.  Negative reviews sometimes have a positive effect on sales. Go figure.

3. As an author myself, I understand the hard work that goes into writing a book. This tale was outside my normal genre. It was better to pray for the author than tearing the story to shreds (a strong temptation - let me tell you).

The last option didn't work either. The story was on such a downward slide that I doubted it could be rescued.

And, no, I'm not naming names or titles!

Writers and Readers: What are your thoughts on this subject?

Photo Credit:  DaVinciS

The Art of Reviewing Books

Yes, I said, "art." As a reviewer, I'm painting a picture for a potential reader. Like a canvas or music, the evaluation of writing is subjective. How I communicate my thoughts will affect their perception of an author's work. I try to remember there's a real, live person who wrote those books. They have feelings, dreams, and it's taken everything for them to put their hearts on the line.

Here are some principles I use to review books:

1.  I select books I enjoy reading. If I detest history (which I don't), why choose a novel set during the Civil War? If horror gives me nightmares (it does), I leave it to braver souls.

2.  I read the descriptions on Amazon. It's irritating to see a review based on someone's disappointment that the content didn't match what they thought the book was about. Even more astonishing is when the reviewer says they didn't read the book.

3.  Give a writer some grace. A debut author's book shouldn't be measured with the yardstick of a seasoned professional's bestseller. A child's first efforts at writing are not in competition with a grad student's thesis. Writing is hard, and we're all on a learning curve.

4.  My number one don't: I rarely review a book under 4 stars. If I know the author and they trust my desire to help them, I might share my thoughts in a private message on what I observed.

5.  Are all my reviews sugar and spice and favorable? No, I'll often point out something that I didn't like. However, I'll also lead and balance those comments with what intrigued, interested, or touched my heart.

Social media and review sites are great when used with kindness and sensitivity. An honest review doesn't equate to trashing an author or their work. My relationship with the Lord affects every area of my life, including how I treat others. It takes a lot to get an agent, a book contract, or even to self-publish. Let's encourage each other to bigger and better things.

Writers:  What are your pet peeves about reviews?

Readers:  What are some of your guidelines for book reviews?

On My Nightstand - From Russia With Love by Susan May Warren

I've seen this author on social media, but I'd never read her books. Oh.my.goodness. From Russia With Love was part of a romance collection that I picked up on a whim, and I'm so glad I did.

Ekaterina (Kat) Hope Moore travels to Russia with a key and a picture on a quest to find her family. From the moment she goes through customs until the end of the story, we're taken on one wild ride.

Vadeem Spasanov, a tough FSB Officer (think KGB), believes Kat is in league with an international smuggler and trails her. He can't figure out what it is about the feisty, escape-artist American that gets under his skin.

When I have to stop reading and I'm frustrated, I always know it's a keeper. Wow, I love romance with a strong element of suspense.  I'll be looking for more of Susan May Warren's books. 5 Stars for this one.

Disclaimer:  Neither the author nor the publisher paid me for a review. All opinions, as usual, are mine and mine alone.

Writers and Readers:  Do you like romances with suspense/mystery? What is your preference: historical or contemporary?

Whats A Reviewer to Do?

You've read a number of books by a Christian author. So, when you see a novel they've written, you pick it up. It's well written - deserving 5 stars - but it's problematic.

Through most of the book, the main characters are committing adultery. It's pivotal to the plot. There are a couple of bedroom scenes. While not extreme, you're thinking of tossing the book on the trash heap.

One character comes to his senses after learning the partner lied to him and used him for their own purposes. He has a conversion experience, and his relationship with his family is restored.

While there's a strong redemptive theme, the book is not only edgy but a banana peel is about to send it over the cliff. Where is this writer going?

Here's my question writers and readers: Do you review the book with appropriate warnings or walk away from the whole issue?

It seems these situations are occurring in Christian books with greater frequency. It's disappointing, but there's no doubt they occur in real life. When the author takes a firm stance, shows the consequences of such behavior, and brings repentance into the picture, is skating that edge okay?

Photo Credit:  John Nyberg

Reviews/Sell Books/Pinterest/Freedom of Religion/Devo

1.  There's been an enormous outcry over Amazon's policy on reviews. Rachelle Gardner, at Books and Such Literary Agency, did a blog post on the subject. Reviews mean a lot to authors. She summarizes the controversy and makes suggestions on how to avoid trouble.

2.  Sandra Beckwith guest posts at Writers Win and shares Six Magic Phrases You Can Use to Sell More Books. Did you know that quoting a person will garner more attention than quoting a publication?

3.  Pinterest is so much fun! I've been looking for some tips on how to create my own pins and found an article on Jody Hedlund's blog. She focuses on writers, but anyone can benefit from her instructions.

4.  WND reports on "freedom of worship" versus "freedom of religion." There's a vast difference between the two.

5.  Dena Netherton, at My Father's World, My Father's Words, talks about their recent move - the truck was too small.

Writers and Readers:  Do you have a Pinterest account? What kind of boards have you created?

Photo Credit:  Jean Scheijen

What Bugs Me About Reviewing Books?

Reading is one of my favorite activities. It's not unusual for me to have 2-3 books going at the same time.

I also enjoy recommending books, but the rating system of stars leaves much to be desired. While I may enjoy the story, perhaps certain aspects of a book don't sit well with me. For example: I've read stories that I loved, but they had some technical/formatting/writing issues.

So...I propose that we have a two-tier system for reviews like the ice skating world. They rate skaters on their technical ability and then on their artistry.

Writers and Readers:  What do you think of my idea? Should I incorporate this into my book recommendations/reviews here on the blog?

Photo Credit:  drivving

On My Nightstand - The Frontiersman's Daughter by Laura Frantz

Lael Click, the daughter of a colorful frontiersman, longs for love. Whispers abound in the settlement concerning her father's ties to the Shawnee. Is he loyal to those in the fort or to his Indian friends?

She's haunted by family secrets, passionate about the Kentucky land where she was raised, and wonders if she'll ever find someone who accepts her unconditionally. Lael lives her life, determined she'll be courageous like her larger-than-life dad.

I first heard of Laura Frantz from a comment she made on a blog. (See visiting blogs and commenting does make a difference.) Little bits and pieces tickled my curiousity until I ordered her book. Wow, I'm so glad I did. What an enjoyable read!

The book is fast-paced and, unlike other romances, I didn't know who she'd marry until almost the end of the book. I liked that surprise element. It kept me engaged, and I couldn't turn the pages fast enough.

Do you like stories about the early days of the United States? What are some of your favorites?

On My Nightstand - The Lightkeeper's Daughter by Colleen Coble

Addie Sullivan and her mother struggle to keep body and soul together as lightkeepers in northern California. Her father's death and her mother's ambivalence toward her make for a sad life.

A stranger appears on their doorstep, injured from a storm. Addie doesn't know what to think when he declares she's really Julia Eaton, the daughter feared dead by her rich family.

Due to some questions, she decides to keep her identity a secret. She travels to the Eaton home and applies for a position as a governess. There she finds love with a widower, but will they have a chance for that happily-ever-after ending?

Mystery and intrigue follow Addie, threaten her life, and the lives of those she loves. Someone doesn't like Julia Eaton intruding on their territory.

Multi-published author, Colleen Coble, creates a historical tale laced with danger. In my humble opinion, I'm pretty good at disciphering mysteries, but she had me stumped.

This book is a winner on all fronts. Colleen's books always find their way onto my Wish List.

On My Nightstand - The Rhythm of Secrets by Patti Lacy - Recommendation/Giveaway!

Due to a scheduling conflict, I've decided to post this book recommendation/giveaway today. Stayed tuned. Details of the giveaway follow my comments.

Sheila Franklin knows how to adapt to changing situations. She's a survivor...at least on the outside. Married to a minister, she's built a life, but one telephone call marks the end of her chameleon existence.

Not only are her secrets revealed, but she must also choose between the man she loves and the son she longs to help. Will she stop running from her past and face it no matter what the cost or once again hide behind her mask?

This is the first book I've read by Patti Lacy, the first of many I hope. (Keep writing, Patti!) She captures the 1940's - 1960's time period from the settings to the attitudes and culture.

Sheila's growth from childhood to 40-something gives an accurate portrayal of a child coping with tragedy, learning, making mistakes, and ultimately getting her life on track. Her speech and thought patterns are always age appropriate.

I read this book in a few days. The story kept drawing me back to see what would happen. The grand finale exploded across the pages, making my heart pound as if I were the character. You don't want to miss this riveting story.

Want an opportunity to win, "The Rhythm of Secrets?" Well, you've come to the right place. :)

1. The giveaway is open to existing Followers and new Followers. Due to various laws, only U.S. residents are eligible. The giveaway is void where prohibited.

2. Comment on this post and leave your email address in the spam-busting format. Example: susanjreinhardt AT _______DOTcom Sorry, no email address = no entry

3. Want an extra entry? Post a link about the contest on your blog, and send me an email with the link to  your post. susanjreinhardt AT gmail DOT com

4. Deadline: Saturday, January 22, 2011, at midnight. The winner will be chosen by random drawing on Sunday, January 23, 2011 and notified via email. A notice will be posted on the blog sometime Sunday.

Disclaimer: The publisher provided me with a copy of this book, but the opinions expressed here are my own. The book is being given away in this contest.

For the reader: Have you ever thought of the 1940's - 1960's as a historical time period? It seems strange to me since I've lived through some of those years. Writers: If you write historicals, is this an era you'd consider?

On My Nightstand - Menu For Romance by Kaye Dacus

Since a close relative is a graduate of Culinary Institute of America and Johnson & Wales, Menu for Romance piqued my interest. Kaye Dacus got the details right.

Watching couples kiss at a New Year's Eve banquet, Meredith Guidry vows that next year she'll be a participant and not an observer. Tired of waiting around for a certain Executive Chef to ask her out, she decides to cut her losses and find someone else.

Major O'Hara, Executive Chef and friend, has made a vow of his own. A delicate family situation and past rejection hampers any thought of marriage and family.

Meredith's interest in handsome contractor, Ward Breaux, wakes him to the possibility of losing her forever. He sets out to win her heart, but is still torn over his unusual circumstances.

I enjoyed the setting, occupation, and characters. Combined with a great story line, this book is a winner. I'm looking forward to more books from Kaye Dacus.

To Recommend or Not Recommend.That is the question.

Last Monday, we discussed reviewing versus recommending books. As a follow-up, I'd like to share my personal convictions on the subject.

Early on, I decided there were several types of books I would not read or recommend. Material that focused on the occult without the truth of the Word of God topped that list. Since fantasy and sci-fi are not enjoyable to me as a reader, I also eliminated them.

Other than these books, I determined to explore new genres. This was a stretch for me as I tend to have favorite authors and stick with them. I've discovered the delights of traipsing through Regency England and the early days of America. Political fiction, contemporary fiction, chick lit, Suspense, and mystery have occupied a place on my nightstand.

Do I recommend books based on the writing or based on my enjoyment as a reader? I don't think I could separate the two aspects of my personality. As a writer, I appreciate a well-written book and can spot lapses. If, however, the story engages me as a reader, I don't think it's necessary to point out minor flaws in excruciating detail. Bottom line: I liked this book, and this is why I found it worthwhile. It doesn't mean it's perfect or that I agree with every single statement.

If I find a book strikes me as horrible, offensive, or boring, I simply don't review it. Out of the many books I've read, only a few fell into these categories. While I'm part of the blog network for several large publishers, I've been extremely choosy about the books I select.

What's your philosophy on the fine art of reviewing/recommending books? Do you feel it's necessary to reveal every flaw even if you enjoyed the story? Since we covered some of these issues in the comments last week, what genres do you enjoy? Have you broadened your reading tastes by sampling other types of fiction?

On My Nightstand - The Atonement Child - by Francine Rivers

Well-known author, Francine Rivers, handles an explosive topic with truth and diplomacy. The Atonement Child tells the story of Dynah Carey, whose perfect life is forever changed by rape and an unwanted pregnancy.

Dynah feels helpless and alone as her fiance, family, and friends struggle with the reality of an uncertain future. All of them agonize as Dynah seeks answers on whether or not to abort her child.

The author deals with the intense fears, suffering, and future considerations of each character. Atonement Child drew me in and gave me a glimpse into the heart of a woman so dreadfully wronged.

This book was my introduction to Francine Rivers' writing. I can see why she's a respected Christian author. I'll be picking up more of her books.

On My Nightstand - The House on Grosvenor Square - By Linore Rose Burkard

Since my foray into Regency Romance began with Linore Rose Burkard's first book, "Before the Season Ends," I looked forward to Ariana's new adventure. She's snagged London's most eligible bachelor, Mr. Mornay, and plans her wedding.

Ah, but all is not peaches and cream. Not everyone is delighted with the match. Her beloved's housekeeper fears Ariana will dismiss her, and she'll be out on the street. Mr. Mornay's enemy is angry and seeks revenge, using Ariana to get back at him.

The author gets Ariana into so much hot water that I want to rescue her. The book has a high tension level and deserves the term Romantic Regency Suspense. This is no tea and crumpets novel. Right to the end, I wondered what other evil would befall our hapless heroine.

If you're a big fan of Regency Romance, you'll love, "The House on Grosvenor Square."

On My Nightstand - The Edge of Recall by Kristen Heitzmann

Tessa Young, a brilliant landscape architect, gets an opportunity to restore a labyrinth based on an old European design. She's torn because her old flame, Smith Chandler, is the one offering the job. Tormented by nightmares from her childhood, she wonders if her fragile mental state can handle working in such close proximity to him. She takes the position, thinking it will give her closure.

Instead, she finds an older and wiser Smith. She fights to maintain a strictly professional relationship, but finds herself attracted to him once again. Her psychiatrist and mentor, Dr. Brenner, warns her two major stressors could result in a breakdown. Yet, Tessa perseveres.

Bizarre happenings threaten to derail the project. Items are moved, others disappear, and the feeling of someone watching them add to her anxiety. Will she finally tame the monsters that haunt her nights and now intrude on her days?

Kristen Heitzmann's masterful handling of Tessa's emotional state and the ultimate revelations concerning her past make this a suspenseful read. She builds the tension to an almost unbearable level before the climax.

This romantic suspense book provided a satisfying story and ending. It's worth picking up.

On My Nightstand - The Familiar Stranger by Christina Berry

Ever since I heard about Christina's book, The Familiar Stranger, I've waited on the edge of my seat for its release. When it arrived via the good ol' U.S. Mail, I tore it open and started reading immediately. For the next two days, every spare moment was spent with my head buried in her book.

Christina nails this story with characters so real you'll expect to bump into them at church. In spite of staggering revelations and bizarre twists, Denise Littleton, manages to overcome her fears of further hurt and trust God with her life. Craig Littleton recovers from a life-threatening accident with no memory of his family or his past. Together, they seek the truth and try to resurrect their dead marriage.

Well written, emotion laden, and a powerful climax, The Familiar Stranger is the must-read book of the season.

On My Nightstand - The Apothecary's Daughter by Julie Klassen

Julie Klassen's Regency era romance sings with strong research and beautifully crafted characters. Her vivid descriptions brought the time period to life.

Lilly won my heart with her thoughtfulness toward her father, brother, and friends. She faced disappointments and hard times with self-denial and courage. Her faith was portrayed in a matter-of-fact manner rather than in a heavy-handed way.

She yearns for travel and adventure. A desire for answers to mysterious events and a longing for love, makes the grass look greener beyond the borders of her village. When the opportunity to spend time in London with her aunt and uncle, she jumps at it. Lilly soon learns everything is not as rosy as it appears.

Fans of historical fiction will find, "The Apothecary's Daughter," a satisfying read. I need to go back and read Julie's debut novel, "The Lady of Milkweed Manor." I don't want to miss any of Julie's books.

On My Nighstand - Oxygen by John B. Olson & Randall Ingermanson

When I go to a bookstore, one section that gets bypassed is Sci-Fi. The whole Trekkie thing (no offense) doesn't do anything for me.

So, what made me pick up Randy Ingermanson and John B. Olson's book, "Oxygen?" Simple. Randy's humor and blog piqued my curiosity. I wanted to see how his teaching translated into a book.

Oxygen is about a NASA mission to Mars. While I remembered the Challenger disaster, the successes always outweighed the failures. After all, airplanes crash, but most flights arrive safely. Oxygen emphasized the dangers and the precision required to achieve NASA's goals.

More than the technical jargon of space travel, the human factor made the book a winner for me. The authors' created believable characters, who dealt with the stress of making decisions based on partial information and colored by their life experience. They filtered into my thoughts and dreams when I had to put the book down.

I particularly liked the way they gave clues to the mystery. The tidbits didn't stand up and shout, "I'm a clue. Remember me." Instead, they were little details the characters noticed, but didn't view as significant until other pieces of the puzzle brought them to mind.

Every aspect of Oxygen held my interest. The authors hit a grand slam with tension, suspense, romance, and the satisfying ending. Thanks, guys, for a book I can give to a male or female, believer or unbeliever.

On My Nightstand - A Whisper of Danger by Catherine Palmer

Catherine Palmer's book, "A Whisper of Danger," is the second book in the Treasures of the Heart series. Once again, the author scores big.

Jessica Thornton and her son, Spencer "Splinter" Thornton, move to Zanzibar after she inherits a house owned by her former art teacher. Upon their arrival, Jess is shocked when she bumps into her estranged husband, Rick.

A treasure hunt, a murder, and a determined husband all conspire to turn Jess' world upside down. Will she let go of her bitterness and resentment? Will she learn to trust again? Mama Hannah, from book 1, provides a strong dose of wisdom, while Jess learns she's not as self-sufficient as she thought.

Loved, loved, loved this book! I whipped through it in two days. (You can imagine how little I got done around here.) Catherine, if you're out there, I'd love to interview you. :)

On My Nightstand-Veiled Freedom by J. M. Windle

Jeanette Windle is a former missionary kid, journalist, and a multi-published author of political suspense. Her experience, extensive research, and sharp writing put her right up there with the leading novelists of our day.

A cynical Special Ops turned Security guy, a naive Christian aide worker, and an embittered young man are brought together in Kabul, Afghanistan. Jeanette explores the issues of culture, religion, and politics with a sensitive, but realistic, touch. Even though the story is fictional, her writing enabled me to see and understand each character's behavior and motivation.

The book portrays the city as teetering on a sharp edge between peace and violence. Small, incremental events, as well as sudden crises, created a growing dread. How could this unbearable tension and conflict be resolved? The climax had me glued to my chair until I ran out of pages.

Veiled Freedom is a must-read book for suspense lovers, as well as those interested in world affairs. I'd read another Jeanette Windle book in a heartbeat.

On My Nightstand - I Have Seen Him In the Watchfires by Cathy Gohlke

Cathy sent me this book awhile ago, but for some unknown reason I didn't get around to reading it until now. I'd look at it, and my hand would go to a different book

When the recent Christy Award winners were announced, I knew why. Cathy won the award for, "I Have Seen Him In The Watchfires," a civil war novel. Congratulations, Cathy! I'm thrilled at your success, and happy to share my thoughts about the book.

Our hero, Robert Glover, is two months away from his 18th birthday. He's chafing under the promise he made his father that he wouldn't enlist in the Union Army until he reached 18.

When a letter arrives from the beautiful Emily in North Carolina, all of his plans take a sudden detour. She informs him her father is in a Union jail at Fort Delaware and begs Robert to visit him. In his effort to find her father, he unwittingly becomes a pawn in an elaborate escape plan.

Through serious illness, old friends, and a Confederate soldier following his dead commander's orders, he moves across enemy lines to help his mother and Emily. Will he make it or will the war consume him and those he loves?

Cathy's second book establishes her as a force to be reckoned with on the Christian writing scene. Don't miss this high tension, down-to-earth view of history.